Sunday, December 29, 2019

[FOR THE PARENTS] Lie to Me by Kaitlin Ward

42898364. sy475

"Lie to Me," by Kaitlin Ward follows the story of a young girl who found herself in the hospital after falling - or being pushed - off a cliff.  The entirety of the book consists of her questioning everyone around her as she tries to find the answers as to what really happened to her.  Was she pushed?  Or was it an unhappy accident?  And if she was pushed, then...who hates her enough to want to kill her?

This was recommended to me by a reluctant reader at the school I'm currently teaching at. She absolutely consumed this book and another by the same author. She's 13, a typical middle school girl and I think the exact demographic that this book is aimed for.

I'm 29, well-read and I figured out the mystery just from reading the back cover. I'm not this book's demographic and it's not a book that is going to transcend ages.  It's very much meant for middle school readers and there's nothing wrong with that. 

I think this is an excellent book for reluctant readers because the action starts from the beginning. It does grab you from the first page and doesn't let you go, which is fantastic for those who find reading boorish.  There's quite a bit of romance and I would even say the romantic aspect is a bit more prominent than the mystery aspect, which I was a bit bummed about, but for young girls, it's certain to keep them entertained.

Most readers will likely gather what the mystery is at least halfway through the book, but there is enough of a creep factor to keep them reading.  

What I liked:
  • The heroine and her brother have a nice relationship
  • Depression is handled delicately and mental illness in general is not portrayed as anything to be ashamed of.
  • Bisexuality is represented well, as is lesbianism.
  • The family unit is solid and there is respect for the parents.
  • Adults are not made out to be the bad guys and are turned to for help.
What I would warn parents about:
  • There is a lot of physical contact; while there is no sex, there is plenty of kissing, handholding, etc.
  • There is one scene in particular where she grabs her boyfriend by the belt in her bedroom while they're kissing; it does imply that they could go further, but they don't
  • There is quite a lot of mention of homosexuality (bisexuality & lesbianism)
Who I would recommend this for:
  • Young people who are questioning their sexuality.
  • Reluctant readers. (Her writing style is very easy to read and flows well.) 

Overall, I think this is a nice 7th or 8th grade book for a quick read and might get those reluctant high school readers finally opening a book! 

No comments:

Post a Comment